Posted by

Buy_Pappy_van_Winkle_BourbonSince this past Saturday, Jan. 2, 2016 when we published this update on the stolen Pappy Van Winkle bottles,  Sheriff Melton tells there now likely won’t be an auction of the bourbons.

Click to listen to full details in our podcast interview above as Melton explains that Julian Van Winkle, President of Old Rip Van Winkle Distillery, has today expressed concerns that the bottles may be tampered.

Sheriff Melton says Julian Van Winkle (pictured below) originally supported the idea of an auction. According to Melton, Circuit Judge Thomas Wingate also expressed his support for the auction.

Melton says that Julian Van Winkle is now concerned that the contents of the sealed bottles could have been tampered with while in the hands of thieves.

Julian_Van_WinkleMelton explains that one concern is a syringe or other mechanism could have been used infect the bottle. While Melton wanted to include a certificate of authenticity and have the auctioned bottles verified as legitimate from strip stamps and / or other methods, he says Julian’s main concern is liability.

As was first to report on an auction, Melton says that our story this past Saturday prompted some inquiries.

“The story we did (on was picked up evidently by AP and we started getting calls yesterday about the bourbon and what our plans were and what we wanted to do,” Melton says. “That has caused quite a stir. At the end of the day, we have abide by what the judge tells us to do.

Circuit Judge Thomas Wingate is the judge who will make the final decision on what will happen to all the stolen bourbon once the case adjudicated. Melton says he believes Wingate will likely follow wishes of Julian Van Winkle. has reached out to Julian Van Winkle for further comment with no response thus far.

“I understand that and totally respect Julian Van Winkle’s decision,” Melton tells us. wants to know if YOU think the stolen Pappy Bourbon should be auctioned or destroyed? Vote in the poll underneath the story below.

Stolen_barrels“We want to see positive come from this; we don’t want anything negative.” Melton says that if by some off chance a thief had done something to a bottle and someone bought it auction, that is not what the Sheriff’s office would want to see happen.

Sheriff melton predicts there will be some activity on the case in the next 30 to 60 days.

Sheriff Melton tells usthat he always wanted to see the stolen Bourbon auctioned for charity but always maintained that the Judge would make the final decision.

In case you’re catching up on our stolen Bourbon updates, we’re including the complete timeline below and subscribe to our Bourbon newsletter for continued updates on the story.

The charities which still may benefit from a possible auction of the stolen barrels are Kentucky Sheriff’s Association Boys and Girls Ranch and United States Marine Corps EOD (for Wounded Warriors and Families of those who have lost service members).

If the auction is held, we have offered to donate a hosted Bourbon tasting in order to help raise funds. Now that the stolen Pappy may not be auctioned, if you have any suggestions or ways to the auction we invite you to contact BourbonBlog or the Franklin County Sherif’s Office.

Additionally, as this is an ongoing investigation, anyone with additional information on bourbon thefts is encouraged to contact Franklin County Sherif’s Office.

Vote in the poll and tell us what you think should happen


Should stolen Pappy be auctioned or destroyed?


Poll Maker


Photo credits: Marvin Joseph/The Washington Post bottles photo.




Timeline in Great Bourbon Syndicate Case from 2013 to Present

10-16-2013 – Pappy Van Winkle Bourbon first reported stolen, first interview with Sheriff Melton   – is first to ask about a possible reward, which is offered later.

10-18-2013  Spotting the Stolen Pappy – is first to raise the question of recorded strip stamp numbers on the bottles of stolen Pappy to aid detectives and consumers in identifying the stolen bottles from any other bottle of Pappy. This is a question that is yet unanswered to this day.

Stolen_pappy_found10-23-2013 Surveillance Footage released  – public asked for help in locating “person of interest.”

10-24-2013 Interview with Liquor Store Where Pappy Suspect Was Caught on Camera – is first to identify Package & More Liquor Store as the location where the “person of interest” was captured on surveillance.

10-27-2013 Bardstown High Principal Chris Pickett Identified as Man in Pappy Surveillance Video

10-28-2013 BourbonBlog interviews Attorney of Chris Pickett  – First interview of its kind with attorney for Chris Pickett.

11-24-2013 Bardstown High School Principal No Longer Person of Interest, interview with Sheriff Melton 

12-02-2013 $10,000 Reward Offered in Pappy Theft Case

04-03-2014 Five Whiskey Worth Stealing organizes historic tasting of other rare bourbons and whiskeys.

12-14-2014 Sheriff Believes He Knows Identity of the “Pappy Thief.” Interview with Sheriff Melton 

Stolen Pappy evidence03-12-2015 Wild Turkey Bourbon Theft Suspect Arrested, Pappy Van Winkle Connection? Interview with Sheriff Melton

4-10-2015 Major Announcement coming in the Bourbon Theft Case 

4-21-2015 Great Bourbon Syndicate: 9 Kentuckians Steal Bourbon for 7 Years
5-19-2015 Former Buffalo Trace Security Guard Indicted in Great Bourbon Syndicate

5-23-2015 Five Accused Members of Great Bourbon Syndicate Enter Plea

6-5-2015 Security Guard and Others To Testify Against Ringleader in Great Bourbon Syndicate

8-7-2015 New Guilty Plea in Stolen Bourbon Case Reveals Crimes Date Back To 2006

8-13-2015 More Stolen Bourbon Recovered


Love Whiskey? Join our weekly whiskey tasting events!

Bourbon Whiskey Tastings

One Response to “Stolen Pappy Now To Be Destroyed and Not Auctioned Due to Wishes of Julian Van Winkle”

  1. Sharon Gaught

    Pour out the bourbon and action the bottles with a certificate of authenticity to the bottles and labels.. Still a collectors item.